The Lone Island Mystery by Emylia Hall

#TheLoneIslandMystery #NetGalley

395 pages

Pub date: 28 April 2026

Five stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

My thoughts:

I am an enormous fan of the Shell House Detectives. Both Ally and Jayden are most likeable characters and each has a backstory that helps readers to get to know them. There are also so many folks surrounding these two and time spent with them is welcome as well. The relationships between the primary and secondary characters make for a quality read.

This is the seventh title in the series. (The eighth is also out). Each book could be read as a standalone but reading them in order lets the reader watch the lives of the characters as they grow and change.

The mystery in this one is very well constructed. A troubled young man named Axel is found dead and battered. The police initially dismiss the case but Ally and Jayden are asked to investigate by the woman who found the body. She lives on the Lone Island of the title.

Axel had recently come to see the Grey family. Their connection reaches into the past. The Grey’s patriarch’s nurse also has a connection to Axel. Pippa may as well (read the book to find out).

The pages kept on turning for me in this traditional mystery. It is long but that just added to the pleasure for me. I recommend this title most highly.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing U.K. for this excellent read. All thoughts are my own.

Post first published on 16 November 2026

Description:

from the publisher

‘Packed with atmosphere, heart and a rising sense of menace.’β€”Gilly Macmillan

‘My favourite cosy crime writer.’β€”Lucy Clarke

A wealthy family. An isolated island. A dead body. Is it a tragic accident or foul play? The Shell House Detectives are investigating again…

Lone Island is a remote and windswept spot, but for nature reserve warden Pippa Grant it’s always been a haven. Until a body washes ashoreβ€”and she’s the one to find it.

The police believe the deceased, Axel Marks, accidentally fell from the cliffs near Porthmerrin House, the grand estate on the mainland where Axel’s mother once served as housekeeper to the Grey family. But Pippa is adamant that there’s more to Axel’s death, and begs Ally and Jayden, the Shell House Detectives, to take the case.

Soon it emerges that Axel had a troubled past, and a complicated history with both Edward Grey and his son, Lucas. As the reasons behind Axel’s visit to Porthmerrin become clear, Ally and Jayden feel sure that the house holds the key, and both owners and staff come under scrutiny. But when the police switch their focus back to Lone Island, Ally and Jayden are forced to question whether it’s their client who has something to hide.

Was Axel murdered out of jealousy and greed, or because of an ancient betrayal? And how far will the killer go to achieve their ultimate goal? As Ally and Jayden finally bring the devastating truth to light, it’s clear that Axel’s death was just the beginning of the story…

Unknown's avatar

Author: joycesmysteryandfictionbookreviews

I love to read, recommend books and open the world of reading to others. I tutor to ensure that the next generation of readers will know the joys of a good book because their reading skills have improved. I am an avid reader, especially of mysteries and fiction. I believe that two of the world's greatest inventions were the public library and eyeglasses!

Leave a Reply